How I Hacked Copywriting Formulas and Increased Open Rates to 43%: A Revealing Journey

In the realm of sales and marketing, effective communication holds the key to success. As I embarked on my journey to optimize my email marketing campaigns, little did I know that I would stumble upon a superpower hidden in plain sight—copywriting formulas. These formulas, like a secret arsenal, possess the ability to captivate readers, evoke emotions, and drive action. Once I tapped into this incredible resource, my open rates skyrocketed to an astonishing 43%. Join me as I unveil the power of copywriting formulas and how they transformed my email marketing game forever. Prepare to unlock the secrets and witness the remarkable results that lie within the realm of copywriting mastery.

Table of Contents

The Experiment

Curious to test the impact of copywriting formulas and headline techniques, I embarked on a personal case study to compare the results of two different writing styles. The first approach mirrored my regular writing style, while the second approach incorporated proven copywriting formulas and attention-grabbing headline techniques. Let’s delve into the details and examine the remarkable differences in open rates, clickthrough rates, and reply rates that I witnessed during this experiment.

Phase 1: Regular Writing Style

In the initial phase, I relied on my standard writing style for crafting cold emails. These emails typically provided a straightforward introduction, a brief description of the product or service, and a call-to-action. While they were concise and clear, I wanted to explore whether incorporating copywriting formulas and headline techniques could enhance their impact.

Phase 2: Copywriting Formulas and Headline Techniques

Inspired by the success stories I had come across, I decided to revamp my cold email approach. I carefully researched and implemented copywriting formulas such as AIDA (Attention, Interest, Desire, Action) and PAS (Problem, Agitation, Solution). Additionally, I utilized attention-grabbing headline techniques to create compelling subject lines that enticed recipients to open the emails. These new emails provided a captivating story, highlighted the pain points and desires of the recipients, and presented a solution that addressed their needs.

Results Analysis:

The impact of incorporating copywriting formulas and headline techniques in my cold email sequences was nothing short of astounding. Let’s examine the statistics and compare the results of the two different writing styles.

Writing Style
Open Rate
Clickthrough Rate
Reply Rate
Regular Writing22%5%12%
Copywriting Formula43%12%21%
  1. Open Rates: With my regular writing style, the average open rate hovered around 22%. While this was decent, I wanted to elevate the level of engagement. Upon implementing the copywriting formulas and attention-grabbing headline techniques, the open rates experienced a remarkable surge. The open rate skyrocketed to an astonishing 43%, doubling the engagement compared to my regular writing style.

  2. Clickthrough Rates: The effectiveness of the new writing style was not limited to open rates alone. Clickthrough rates, a crucial indicator of recipient interest and engagement, also witnessed a significant improvement. The incorporation of copywriting formulas and headline techniques resulted in a remarkable 7% increase in clickthrough rates compared to my regular writing style.

  3. Reply Rates: The ultimate goal of cold email outreach is to initiate meaningful conversations and generate valuable responses. The power of copywriting formulas and headline techniques became evident in the substantial boost in reply rates. With my regular writing style, the reply rate averaged around 12%. However, with the revamped approach, the reply rate surged to an impressive 21%, nearly doubling the level of engagement and interaction with recipients.

Overview of the Framework for a Successful Sales Email

Before delving into specific email types, it’s essential to understand the overarching framework for a successful sales email. Regardless of the approach, a well-crafted sales email should include the following elements:

  1. Personalization: Address the recipient by their name and tailor the content to their specific needs and pain points.

  2. Attention-Grabbing Subject Line: Create a subject line that piques curiosity, addresses a pain point, or offers a compelling benefit to entice the recipient to open the email.

  3. Engaging Opening: Capture the reader’s attention from the very beginning with a captivating opening line that sparks interest and compels them to read further.

  4. Clear Value Proposition: Clearly communicate the unique value or benefit your product or service offers and how it addresses the recipient’s needs.

  5. Call-to-Action (CTA): Provide a clear and concise call-to-action that directs the recipient towards the desired next step, whether it’s scheduling a demo, making a purchase, or requesting more information.

Now, let’s explore three different types of sales emails and understand how to effectively use them.

Storytelling in a Sales Email

Storytelling is a powerful technique that can engage emotions and create a memorable connection with the reader. Here’s an example of how storytelling can be integrated into a sales email:

Subject: From Struggling to Success: How XYZ Product Transformed My Business

Body: Hi [Prospect’s Name],

I hope this email finds you well. I wanted to share a story with you that might resonate, as I believe it mirrors the challenges you may be facing in your business.

Just a few months ago, I was struggling to manage my growing workload and keep up with the demands of my clients. I was on the verge of burnout and felt overwhelmed. That’s when I discovered XYZ Product—a game-changer that revolutionized the way I operate my business.

XYZ Product not only streamlined my processes but also provided me with invaluable insights and tools to enhance productivity. With its intuitive interface and powerful features, I was able to reclaim my time, focus on high-value tasks, and deliver exceptional results to my clients.

I wanted to share this success story with you because I genuinely believe that XYZ Product can have the same transformative impact on your business. If you’re interested in exploring how it can revolutionize your operations and boost your efficiency, I’d be more than happy to arrange a personalized demo for you.

Let’s take the first step towards unlocking your business’s full potential. Reply to this email or give me a call at [Phone Number], and we can schedule a demo at your convenience.

Best regards, [Your Name]

Explanation: This email incorporates storytelling by introducing a relatable problem and describing how the XYZ Product solved it. The personal experience adds credibility and fosters a sense of trust between the sender and the recipient. The email concludes with a personalized CTA, offering a demo to explore the solution further.

Straight-Up Sales Email

In certain situations, a direct and concise sales email can be highly effective. Here’s an example of a straight-up sales email:

Subject: Introducing the Revolutionary ABC Software – Boost Your Business Today!

Body: Hi [Prospect’s Name],

Are you tired of struggling with outdated software that hampers your productivity and limits your growth potential? Look no further. ABC Software is here to revolutionize the way you run your business.

With its cutting-edge features and user-friendly interface, ABC Software is designed to streamline your operations, save you time, and maximize your profitability. From seamless inventory management to robust analytics, our software empowers businesses like yours to achieve unprecedented efficiency and profitability.

Don’t let your competitors leave you behind. It’s time to upgrade to ABC Software and unlock a world of possibilities. Take action today by clicking the link below to schedule a demo or give us a call at [Phone Number].

Click here [CTA] to revolutionize your business!

Best regards, [Your Name]

Explanation: This email gets straight to the point, highlighting the pain points faced by the recipient and presenting ABC Software as the ultimate solution. The emphasis is on the benefits and competitive advantage that the software offers. The email concludes with a strong CTA, urging the recipient to take action immediately.

Behind-the-Scenes Sales Email

A behind-the-scenes approach can help build trust and credibility by offering a glimpse into your company’s culture and processes. Here’s an example:

Subject: Exclusive Sneak Peek: How We Create High-Quality Widgets

Body: Hello [Prospect’s Name],

We hope you’re having a fantastic day! We wanted to share an exclusive behind-the-scenes look at our widget production process to give you an insight into the craftsmanship that goes into creating each and every one of our products.

At WidgetWorks, we pride ourselves on our commitment to quality and innovation. Our team of skilled artisans meticulously crafts each widget, ensuring precision, durability, and exceptional performance. From the selection of top-grade materials to the final inspection, our process is driven by a passion for excellence.

We understand that you value high-quality products that deliver tangible results. That’s why we wanted to extend an exclusive offer to you. For a limited time, we are offering a 20% discount on all our widgets as a token of appreciation for your interest and support.

Visit our website [CTA] and use the code BEHINDTHESCENES20 at checkout to avail yourself of this special discount. We can’t wait for you to experience the superior quality and performance of WidgetWorks products firsthand.

If you have any questions or would like more information, please don’t hesitate to reach out. We’re here to assist you in any way we can.

Best regards, [Your Name]

Explanation: This email provides a behind-the-scenes perspective, giving the recipient an understanding of the company’s dedication to quality and craftsmanship. It also includes an exclusive offer to incentivize immediate action. The CTA is clear and encourages the recipient to visit the website and make a purchase using the provided discount code.

Always Remember the Follow-Up Emails

Follow-up emails are an integral part of the sales process. They provide an opportunity to re-engage prospects who may not have responded to previous emails. Some key points to keep in mind when crafting follow-up emails include:

  • Persistence without being pushy: Send gentle reminders to keep your product or service top of mind, emphasizing its value.

  • Offer additional incentives: Consider providing exclusive offers or additional information to entice the recipient to take action.

  • Personalize the follow-up: Reference previous interactions or discussions to demonstrate that you value the relationship and are attentive to their needs.

Don’t Forget To Warm Up Your Email Account Before You Send!

Effective Sales Email Templates

To assist you in crafting compelling sales emails, here are four effective templates that incorporate the framework we’ve discussed:

  1. Template for Initial Contact:

Subject: [Prospect’s Company] + [Your Company]: A Winning Partnership?

Body: Hi [Prospect’s Name],

I recently came across [Prospect’s Company] and was blown away by your innovative approach to [specific industry/area]. As a fellow trailblazer in the field, I believe that our companies could create a powerful synergy that leads to mutual success.

I’d love to connect with you to explore potential collaboration opportunities. Can we schedule a quick call next week to discuss how our complementary expertise can drive extraordinary results for both our organizations?

Looking forward to hearing from you.

Best regards, [Your Name]

  1. Template for Reengagement:

Subject: Reconnect and Rediscover [Your Product/Service]

Body: Hi [Prospect’s Name],

I hope this email finds you well. It’s been some time since we last connected, and I wanted to reach out and see if you’re still interested in exploring how [Your Product/Service] can transform your [specific area].

We’ve made several exciting updates and enhancements since we last spoke, and I believe now is the perfect time for you to rediscover the immense value our solution provides. I’d be thrilled to schedule a follow-up call or demo to showcase the latest features and discuss how they align with your goals.

Let me know your availability, and we’ll find a time that works best for you.

Looking forward to reconnecting soon.

Best regards, [Your Name]

  1. Template for Exclusive Offer:

Subject: Exclusive Offer: Unlock 30 Days of [Your Service] for Free!

Body: Hi [Prospect’s Name],

As a valued member of our community, we wanted to express our gratitude by extending an exclusive offer to you. For a limited time, we are offering a 30-day free trial of [Your Service]. This is your chance to experience firsthand how our solution can revolutionize your [specific area] and drive exceptional results.

To claim your exclusive offer, simply click the link below and sign up. Don’t miss this opportunity to discover the power of [Your Service].

Click here to claim your exclusive offer [CTA].

Best regards, [Your Name]

  1. Template for Follow-Up:

Subject: Quick Follow-Up: Let’s Continue the Conversation

Body: Hi [Prospect’s Name],

I hope you’re doing well. I wanted to touch base and see if you had any further questions or if there’s anything else I can assist you with regarding [Your Product/Service].

Our team is here to provide you with the support you need and ensure that you have all the information necessary to make an informed decision. Please feel free to reach out if there’s anything specific you’d like to discuss or if you’d like to schedule a call.

Looking forward to continuing the conversation.

Best regards, [Your Name]

SECRET SAUCE: Harnessing Copywriting Formulas for Email Success

One of the most impactful techniques in email copywriting is the use of proven formulas that grab attention, engage the reader, and drive action. In this section, we will drill down on the real secret sauce… copywriting formulas and provide practical examples of how they can be applied to create compelling sales emails.

The AIDA Formula: Attract, Interest, Desire, Action

The AIDA formula is a classic copywriting framework that has stood the test of time. It focuses on guiding readers through a logical progression of stages, ultimately leading them to take action. Let’s see how it can be applied to a sales email:

Subject: Boost Your Productivity with XYZ Software

Body: Hello [Prospect’s Name],

Are you tired of wasting valuable time on repetitive tasks? Imagine a world where you can streamline your workflow, save hours each day, and achieve more than ever before. Introducing XYZ Software, the ultimate productivity tool designed specifically for professionals like you.

With XYZ Software, you can automate tedious processes, centralize your data, and collaborate seamlessly with your team. Our powerful features include:

  • Task automation: Eliminate repetitive tasks and focus on what truly matters.
  • Data management: Consolidate and organize your information in one centralized location.
  • Team collaboration: Effortlessly communicate, assign tasks, and track progress.

Don’t let inefficiency hold you back from reaching your full potential. Join the thousands of professionals who have already experienced the transformative power of XYZ Software.

Click here [CTA] to schedule a personalized demo with one of our experts and discover how XYZ Software can revolutionize your workflow.

Best regards, [Your Name]

Explanation: The subject line grabs attention by addressing a pain point and promising a solution. The body of the email attracts the reader’s interest by painting a vivid picture of the benefits they can achieve. It creates desire by highlighting the key features and how they can improve the reader’s life. Finally, it drives action by providing a clear call-to-action (CTA) and offering a personalized demo.

PAS Formula: Problem, Agitation, Solution

The PAS formula is particularly effective when targeting prospects who are already aware of a problem but may not have found the right solution. Here’s an example of how it can be employed:

Subject: Say Goodbye to Back Pain

Body: Hi [Prospect’s Name],

Is your back pain holding you back from enjoying life to the fullest? It’s time to regain control and find the relief you deserve. At XYZ Chiropractic, we understand the challenges you face and have helped thousands of individuals like you overcome their pain.

The Problem: Back pain affects millions of people, making everyday activities a struggle. It restricts your mobility, dampens your mood, and hampers your overall well-being.

The Agitation: You’ve likely tried various remedies, but temporary relief is not enough. You need a lasting solution that addresses the root cause and provides sustainable results.

The Solution: Our team of experienced chiropractors specializes in personalized treatments tailored to your specific needs. Through a combination of gentle adjustments, therapeutic exercises, and lifestyle recommendations, we can help you achieve long-term relief and regain your quality of life.

Don’t let back pain dictate your daily activities any longer. Call us today at [Phone Number] to schedule a consultation and take the first step towards a pain-free future.

Best regards, [Your Name]

Explanation: The subject line immediately addresses the reader’s pain point, creating a sense of empathy. The body of the email acknowledges the problem, agitates it by emphasizing its negative impact, and then introduces the solution—highlighting the benefits of seeking professional help. The email concludes with a clear call-to-action, urging the reader to schedule a consultation.

FOMO Formula: Fear of Missing Out

The FOMO formula capitalizes on the fear of missing out to encourage immediate action. Here’s an example of how it can be applied:

Subject: Limited-Time Offer: 50% Off All Summer Styles!

Body: Hey [Prospect’s Name],

Summer is here, and so is the hottest deal of the season! For a limited time, we’re offering an exclusive 50% discount on all our summer styles. Don’t miss your chance to upgrade your wardrobe and turn heads wherever you go.

Imagine walking down the beach in the trendiest outfits, feeling confident and stylish. Our summer collection is carefully curated to keep you cool, comfortable, and ahead of the fashion curve. From vibrant swimwear to breezy dresses, we have everything you need to make a splash this summer.

But hurry, this offer won’t last long! Visit our website [CTA] now and use the code SUMMER50 at checkout to enjoy this incredible discount. Remember, summer waits for no one.

Wishing you a stylish and sun-soaked season,

[Your Name]

Explanation: The subject line highlights the limited-time offer, creating a sense of urgency. The body of the email focuses on the benefits of the summer collection and the feelings it can evoke. It encourages the reader to take immediate action by providing a clear CTA and emphasizing that the offer is time-sensitive.


Mastering the art of writing effective sales emails requires understanding the psychology of persuasion and utilizing copywriting formulas that have proven successful. By employing techniques like the AIDA formula, PAS formula, and FOMO formula, you can create compelling sales emails that capture attention, engage the reader, and drive conversions. Remember to customize these templates to align with your product or service and maintain a genuine tone that resonates with your target audience. Happy writing and successful selling!

Play Video
  • 14 Days FREE Trial
  • HUGE Company Database
  • Half A Billion Contacts to Search
  • No Credit Card Required

Get Unlimited Email Addresses & Phone Numbers At The Click Of A Button

Scroll to Top
No Credit Card Needed!
Find Unlimited Verified Contacts from LinkedIn